AUT Under Review
Eight operational reviews at AUT since October have cut 45 full-time jobs – with 14 more pending. Areas being reviewed include programmes, departments or whole schools at the university. With the possibility of more reviews on the way and a possible change in teaching style for AUT, some lecturers are concerned.
The AUT chair of the Association of Staff in Tertiary Education (ASTE), John Prince, says there is a “range of feelings” among staff.
“Some [lecturers] are concerned for their jobs obviously, and others are concerned because of a loss of contact with students and a changing style of teaching.”
AUT has a number of rationales behind the reviews, including finance and student-to-staff ratio.
However, there is another underlying cause for the recent reviews. The
Government changed the way universities are funded at the end of 2007.
“Ninety percent of our income would have been paid by students. The
new funding regime means only 70 percent of the funding now comes from
students,” says Prince.
The rest of the funding will be “a complicated combination of things like the PBRF ratings and research done”, says Prince.
AUT says the new funding regime isn’t the only reason cutbacks needed to be made.
Nigel Murphy, spokesperson for the Vice-Chancellor Derek McCormack,
said the entire university sector was “under-funded and has been for
many years”.
“AUT is certainly not alone in being fiscally challenged.”
The NZ Vice Chancellors Committee released a statement that pointed
out “international student enrolments have been falling for several
years, which has a direct impact on all universities’ bottom lines”.
One trend from the reviews so far is the loss of mainly certificates and diplomas, rather than degrees.
AUT confirmed it was “reviewing certain programmes – especially
pre-degree – as well as admin and support structures, to look for ways
to become more effective and efficient. Other universities are doing
the same”.
This has come from pressure by the Government to increase the ratio
of degrees to non-degrees at AUT which is currently around 66 per cent
degrees and 34 per cent non-degrees.
The Government has recently been pushing trades and
apprenticeships, which according to Prince is a good thing but when it
comes to universities its view is clear.
“They want us to do less certificates and diplomas,” he says.
One person concerned about this is Jan Herman, president of AuSM.
Herman says: “We were quite concerned that the Government wanted to
make universities in particular not able to just teach anything they
wanted. They were being dictated to and this could affect students.”
Student debt is another reason Herman believes the Government is
wrong. “If a course isn’t offered in Auckland because it is not
considered necessary by the Government, the student has to move outside
Auckland. This will cost so much more in living and they will come out
with major debt.”
Some of the courses cut are the Certificate of Pharmacy Technology,
Certificate of Cultural Tourism and Travel, five smaller art and design
certificates, two engineering certificates and the New Zealand Diploma
of Business.
“We were quite concerned when we heard the New Zealand diploma of
business had been cut. I have met a few students who were coming to AUT
just to do it,” says Herman.
There may be more reviews to come and apart from the obvious losses
like jobs and courses AUT’s teaching style of more lecturer interaction
and support, and smaller classes may suffer. The model other
universities like Otago and Auckland use involves a smaller amount of
lecture time and tutors in the form of other students.
Prince says: “The University of Auckland has undergraduate classes
with up to 700 people in them. Only two lecturers and many student
tutors make costs low. But AUT doesn’t do that.”
The teaching style at AUT would be its biggest loss, according to Herman.
“I just graduated in my double degree a few weeks ago and I think
I’m better for it through the amount of interaction I’ve had with
lecturers outside the classroom. It’s one of the main reasons I came to
AUT, because of the teaching style.”
Though it may eventually have to happen, Prince believes students
are safe for the time being. “AUT will have a long way to go before we
change from what we are now to a university like Auckland or Otago.”